is a slip lead better than a harness 4
is a slip lead better than a harness 4

When it comes to walking our beloved furry companions, the age-old debate reigns on: is a slip lead better than a harness? We hear conflicting opinions from fellow dog owners, experts, and even our own intuition sometimes. In this article, we aim to provide clarity and shed light on the pros and cons of both options, so that we can make an informed decision that ensures the utmost comfort and safety for our four-legged friends. Let’s delve into the world of slip leads and harnesses, exploring their benefits and considerations, and ultimately, answering the burning question: which reigns supreme?

Support for Slip Leads

Ease of Use

One of the main benefits of using a slip lead for your dog is its ease of use. Slip leads are simple to put on and take off, making them a convenient choice for daily walks or outdoor activities. With just a quick slip over your dog’s head and a pull of the lead, you can easily secure the slip lead around their neck. This simplicity makes it an ideal option for dog owners who may struggle with more complex harness systems.


Slip leads provide excellent control over your dog’s movements. The design of a slip lead allows you to easily control their direction and behavior with just a slight tug on the lead. This control is particularly useful in situations where you need to quickly correct your dog’s behavior or redirect their attention. Whether you’re navigating a busy street or encountering distractions on a trail, a slip lead can give you the confidence and control you need to keep your dog safe and well-behaved.

Quick Corrections

In addition to control, slip leads also offer the advantage of quick corrections. The design of a slip lead allows for instantaneous feedback when your dog pulls or becomes unruly. A gentle tug on the lead can provide a clear message to your dog, signaling that their behavior is not acceptable. This immediate correction can be more effective in shaping their behavior compared to the delayed feedback that may occur with other harnesses or leashes.

Outdoor Activities

For outdoor enthusiasts and adventure-loving dogs, slip leads are a popular choice. Their lightweight and minimalistic design make them suitable for a wide range of activities such as hiking, trail running, and backpacking. Slip leads allow your dog to move freely and comfortably without the added weight or restrictions of a harness. Additionally, slip leads are less likely to get caught on branches or obstacles during outdoor excursions, making them a safer option for exploring nature with your canine companion.

Benefits of Harnesses


Harnesses are widely recognized for their comfort. Unlike slip leads that are secured around the neck, harnesses distribute pressure evenly across the chest and shoulders, reducing the strain on your dog’s neck. This even distribution of pressure can be particularly beneficial for dogs with health conditions or those prone to pulling. By putting less stress on their neck, harnesses provide a more comfortable walking experience for your furry friend, promoting overall well-being and enjoyment during outdoor activities.


Harnesses offer enhanced safety features compared to slip leads. The design of a harness ensures that the pressure from pulling is distributed over a larger area, minimizing the risk of injury or discomfort. This is especially important for dogs with delicate necks, brachycephalic breeds, or dogs prone to respiratory issues. Additionally, harnesses often have reflective or high-visibility materials to improve visibility during low-light conditions, increasing the safety of walks or outdoor adventures.

Reduced Strain

One of the primary advantages of using a harness is the reduced strain it places on your dog’s body. Whether you have a strong and enthusiastic puller or a smaller, less physically robust dog, harnesses can help alleviate the strain on their muscles and joints. By distributing the force of pulling across their body, harnesses prevent the concentrated strain that can lead to discomfort or even injury in the long term. This is particularly important for larger breeds or dogs that tend to pull excessively.

Even Distribution of Pressure

Harnesses with a front-clip or back-clip design offer the benefit of evenly distributing pressure when your dog pulls on the leash. A front-clip harness attaches the leash to the front of the chest, whereas a back-clip harness attaches the leash on the back. Both options work by redirecting the pulling force towards the center of your dog’s body, promoting better alignment and reducing the likelihood of injury. This even distribution of pressure helps to discourage pulling behavior and provides a more comfortable and controlled walking experience.

Is A Slip Lead Better Than A Harness?

This image is property of

Personal Preferences

Dog’s Size and Breed

When deciding between a slip lead and a harness, it’s important to consider your dog’s size and breed. Smaller dogs or breeds with delicate necks may be more suited to a harness that distributes pressure evenly, reducing strain and potential injury. On the other hand, larger and stronger breeds may benefit from the control and quick corrections provided by a slip lead. Understanding your dog’s unique needs and physical capabilities can help you choose the right equipment for them.

Training Style

Your preferred training style can also influence your choice between a slip lead and a harness. Slip leads are often used in conjunction with positive reinforcement training techniques, allowing for quick and effective corrections when needed. If you prefer a training method that focuses on redirecting your dog’s attention or rewarding desired behaviors, a slip lead may be the better option for you. Harnesses, on the other hand, can be used with various training styles and are particularly beneficial for dogs who need consistent reinforcement without the risk of choking or discomfort.

Walking Environment

Consider the type of environment in which you and your dog walk. Slip leads are suitable for walking in familiar and controlled environments, such as quiet neighborhoods or calm parks. However, if you frequently encounter distractions like other dogs, squirrels, or loud noises, a harness may provide better control and comfort for your dog. The additional support and reduced strain can prove invaluable in managing your dog’s behavior and keeping them safe in more challenging walking environments.

Leash Pulling Behavior

If your dog has a tendency to pull on the leash, their behavior should also be a factor in your decision-making process. While a slip lead can provide quick corrections for pulling, harnesses with front-clip or no-pull features are specifically designed to address this behavior. These harnesses employ additional mechanisms, such as a front attachment point or chest straps, to discourage pulling and redirect your dog’s attention towards you. If pulling is a constant struggle during walks, a harness designed to discourage this behavior may be worth considering.

Training and Behavior Considerations

Positive Reinforcement Training

Regardless of whether you choose to use a slip lead or a harness, positive reinforcement training techniques are essential for creating a strong and healthy bond with your furry friend. Rewarding desired behaviors with treats, praise, or toys helps to reinforce positive associations and encourages your dog to repeat those behaviors. Positive reinforcement also promotes trust, confidence, and cooperation, leading to a more enjoyable walking experience for both you and your dog.

Leash Reactivity

If your dog displays leash reactivity, such as lunging or barking at other dogs or people, additional training and behavior management strategies may be necessary. Slip leads can provide quick corrections to redirect their attention, but it’s important to address the root cause of the reactivity through positive reinforcement training and desensitization techniques. Harnesses may be a valuable tool in managing leash-reactive behavior as they offer better control, support, and can assist in redirecting your dog’s focus away from potential triggers.

Escape Artists

For dogs that are skilled at escaping their collars or harnesses, extra precautions should be taken. Slip leads, although not escape-proof, provide less opportunity for dogs to wiggle out of their equipment compared to harnesses. However, it’s crucial to ensure that the slip lead is properly fitted and not too loose, as a dog may still be able to maneuver their way out if not secured tightly. Harnesses with additional security features, such as buckles or chest straps, can provide a more secure fit but may require additional training for your dog to adjust to the new equipment.

Is A Slip Lead Better Than A Harness?

This image is property of

Slip Leads and Harnesses for Specific Activities

Daily Walks

Both slip leads and harnesses are suitable for daily walks, but the choice ultimately depends on your preferences and your dog’s specific needs. Slip leads excel in providing quick corrections and control, making them a great option for well-behaved dogs or those in training. Harnesses, on the other hand, prioritize comfort and support, ensuring your dog’s physical well-being during walks. Consider factors such as your dog’s behavior, size, and any training goals when deciding which equipment to use for your daily walks.

Running or Jogging

If you enjoy running or jogging with your dog, a harness is often the preferred choice. The even distribution of pressure and reduced strain on your dog’s neck and shoulders make harnesses a safer and more comfortable option for high-impact activities. Harnesses with a front-clip design can also provide better control and prevent pulling, allowing for a smoother and more enjoyable run or jog. Before engaging in any intense physical activity, it’s important to ensure that your dog is properly conditioned and able to handle the exercise.

Hiking or Backpacking

When venturing into the great outdoors for hiking or backpacking adventures, both slip leads and harnesses have their advantages. Slip leads are lightweight, easy to pack, and offer a convenient option for well-behaved dogs in controlled environments. However, if your dog tends to pull or requires extra support on challenging terrain, a harness may be the better choice. Harnesses provide enhanced control, reduce strain on your dog’s body during long hikes, and offer the option to attach additional gear such as backpacks or safety lights.

Agility Training

Agility training requires precise control and coordination, making a harness the ideal choice for this activity. Harnesses offer the ability to make quick adjustments and provide better body alignment, ensuring your dog can move freely and fluidly through obstacle courses. The added support and reduced strain on their neck and shoulders can help prevent injuries and promote optimal performance. Slip leads, although suitable for basic obedience commands during agility training, may not offer the same level of control and stability needed for advanced maneuvers.

Understanding Slip Leads

Design and Functionality

Slip leads, also known as slip collars or choke chains, consist of a looped lead that tightens around your dog’s neck when tension is applied. The design allows for a quick and easy on/off application and offers control through slight adjustments in pressure. Slip leads are often made of nylon or leather, providing durability and strength. It’s important to note that slip leads should only be used as intended and under the guidance of a professional trainer if you are unfamiliar with their proper usage.

Correct Fit

When using a slip lead, it’s essential to ensure a proper and comfortable fit for your dog. The slip lead should be snug enough to prevent your dog from slipping out, but not so tight that it restricts their breathing or causes discomfort. As a general rule, you should be able to fit two fingers between the slip lead and your dog’s neck. Regularly check the fit and adjust as needed, especially if your dog is still growing or if they have lost weight. It’s also important to monitor your dog’s neck for any signs of irritation or chafing from prolonged use.

Potential Risks

While slip leads can be effective training tools when used correctly, they do carry certain risks. The tightening action of a slip lead can potentially cause injury if misused or applied with excessive force. It’s essential to avoid any jerking or yanking motions that may harm your dog. Additionally, dogs with certain medical conditions, such as respiratory issues or neck injuries, should not use slip leads. If you have concerns about using a slip lead or are unsure of its suitability for your dog, consult with a professional trainer or veterinarian for guidance.

Is A Slip Lead Better Than A Harness?

This image is property of

Exploring Harness Types

Step-In Harness

Step-in harnesses are designed for ease of putting on and taking off. They typically have a loop that your dog’s legs step into, and a fastening mechanism secures the harness around their body. Step-in harnesses are popular for smaller dogs or dogs with limited mobility as they provide minimal strain on their legs or joints. However, the simplicity of their design may not offer the same level of control and support as other harness types, making them more suitable for well-behaved dogs.

Back-Clip Harness

Back-clip harnesses have a D-ring attachment on the back, allowing you to clip the leash to the harness. This design offers comfort and is easy to put on, making it a popular choice for everyday walks. Back-clip harnesses provide some control and prevent pulling to a certain extent. However, they may not be as effective for dogs that are prone to pulling or have a tendency to lunge forward. Back-clip harnesses offer a good balance between comfort and control, making them suitable for many dogs.

Front-Clip Harness

Front-clip harnesses have a D-ring attachment on the front of the chest, which provides better control and redirects your dog’s pulling force towards you. This design discourages pulling behavior and encourages your dog to walk beside you. Front-clip harnesses are particularly helpful for dogs that tend to pull excessively or need additional support in controlling their forward momentum. They offer improved control without compromising comfort, making them an excellent option for dogs in training or those with leash reactivity.

No-Pull Harness

No-pull harnesses are specifically designed to address pulling behavior. They often feature both a front-clip and back-clip attachment point, providing maximum control and versatility. The dual-attachment design allows you to choose the most suitable attachment point based on your dog’s behavior and training needs. No-pull harnesses apply gentle pressure to the chest when your dog pulls, encouraging them to redirect their attention and walk beside you. These harnesses can be highly effective in providing control and reducing pulling behavior on walks.

Choosing the Right Equipment

Consulting a Professional

Choosing the right equipment for your dog can be overwhelming, especially with the wide variety of options available. If you’re unsure which option is best for your dog, it’s always beneficial to consult with a professional dog trainer or veterinarian. They can assess your dog’s unique needs, behavior, and physical condition to provide personalized recommendations and guidance. Their expertise and experience will ensure that you choose the most suitable equipment for your dog’s comfort, safety, and training goals.

Considering Your Dog’s Needs

Every dog is unique, so it’s crucial to consider their specific needs when selecting equipment. Take into account factors such as their size, breed, age, and any existing health conditions. For example, a larger dog with a history of neck or joint issues may benefit from the added support and reduced strain of a harness. Conversely, a well-behaved and trained smaller breed dog may thrive with the control and quick corrections provided by a slip lead. By considering your dog’s individual needs, you can choose equipment that promotes their overall well-being and enjoyment during walks and outdoor activities.

Trying Different Options

Finding the perfect equipment for your dog may require some trial and error. It’s worth trying different options, such as slip leads and various harness designs, to determine what works best for your dog. Observe their behavior, comfort level, and response to different types of equipment. Every dog has distinct preferences, and what works for one dog may not work for another. By exploring different options, you can identify which equipment provides the right balance of control, comfort, and safety for your unique furry companion.

Prioritizing Comfort and Safety

When choosing equipment for your dog, comfort and safety should be top priorities. Ensure that the equipment fits properly, avoiding anything too tight or restrictive. Pay attention to signs of discomfort, such as excessive rubbing, chafing, or resistance when putting on the equipment. Additionally, prioritize safety features such as reflective materials or high-visibility colors for increased visibility during walks in low-light conditions. Comfortable and safe equipment will not only enhance your dog’s walking experience but also foster a positive and enjoyable bond between you and your canine companion.

Is A Slip Lead Better Than A Harness?

This image is property of

Combining Slip Leads and Harnesses

Using Both for Different Purposes

In some cases, combining a slip lead and a harness can be advantageous. For example, you may use a slip lead for quick corrections during training sessions or in controlled environments, and utilize a harness for longer walks or outdoor activities that require more support and comfort. This combination allows you to have the best of both worlds, providing control, ease of use, and quick adjustments when needed, while also prioritizing your dog’s physical well-being and reducing strain during more extended periods of activity.

Transitioning Between Equipment

If you decide to transition between a slip lead and a harness, it’s important to introduce the new equipment gradually. Begin by incorporating short training sessions with the new equipment, gradually increasing the duration. Use positive reinforcement techniques to help your dog associate the new equipment with positive experiences. By taking the time to acclimate your dog to the new equipment and reinforcing desired behaviors during the transition, you can ensure a smooth and successful shift from one type of equipment to another.

Customizing Training Techniques

Combining a slip lead and a harness also allows you to customize your training techniques based on your dog’s specific needs and behaviors. For example, you can utilize the slip lead during obedience training sessions to provide quick corrections for undesirable behaviors, and then switch to a harness for loose leash walking or activities that require better control and comfort. By tailoring your training techniques to fit the situation, you can effectively address your dog’s behavior and ensure they have the appropriate support and control in various contexts.


Personality and Behavior Assessment

When deciding between a slip lead and a harness, it’s important to consider your dog’s unique personality and behavior. Factors such as size, breed, training goals, and any existing health conditions should all be taken into account to ensure the equipment you choose meets their specific needs. A behavioral assessment can help identify any issues or challenges that may influence the type of equipment that is most suitable for your dog.

Trial and Error

Finding the right equipment may involve some trial and error. Each dog is different, and what works for one may not work for another. Don’t be discouraged if your initial choice doesn’t provide the desired results. Be open to trying different options and be observant of your dog’s comfort, behavior, and response. Adjustments may be needed along the way to find the perfect fit for your furry friend.

Maintaining Open Communication with Your Dog

Regardless of the equipment you choose, maintaining open communication with your dog is essential. Pay attention to their body language, signals, and comfort level during walks or training sessions. Regularly check the fit of the equipment and ensure it is comfortable and properly adjusted. Dogs are highly perceptive and will respond positively when they feel understood and respected. By fostering a strong bond and open communication, you can create a positive and enjoyable walking experience for both you and your beloved canine companion.

Is A Slip Lead Better Than A Harness?

This image is property of

Previous articleWhat Device Stops Neighbors Dogs From Barking?
Next articleCan You Recommend A Durable Dog Leash For A Large Breed?
Brian Moore
I'm Brian Moore, a veterinarian with over 10 years of experience. I graduated from the University of California, Davis School of Veterinary Medicine in 2012. After graduation, I worked as a general practitioner in a small animal clinic for several years. In 2017, I opened my own veterinary practice, Moore Animal Hospital. I'm passionate about providing compassionate and high-quality care to all animals. I'm skilled in a wide range of veterinary procedures, including surgery, dentistry, and internal medicine. I'm also a certified animal behaviorist, and I take a special interest in helping animals with behavioral problems. In addition to my clinical work, I'm also active in the veterinary community. I'm a member of the American Veterinary Medical Association and the California Veterinary Medical Association. I'm also a frequent speaker at veterinary conferences. I'm dedicated to providing the best possible care for my patients and their families. I'm a compassionate and knowledgeable veterinarian who is always willing to go the extra mile. I'm originally from San Francisco, California. I'm married and have two children. I enjoy hiking, camping, and spending time with my family. I'm also a member of the local animal shelter and volunteer my time to help care for homeless animals. I'm excited to continue my career as a veterinarian and help even more animals in need.