do dogs pull more with a harness 3
do dogs pull more with a harness 3

When it comes to dog walking, many pet owners face the dilemma of using a collar or a harness. But have you ever wondered if harnessing encourages dogs to pull more?

This article explores this intriguing question and the potential reasons behind dogs’ behavior when wearing a harness.

So, if you’re a dog lover seeking insights on the best way to walk your furry friend, keep reading to discover the surprising truth behind dogs and harnesses.

Do Dogs Pull More With A Harness?

The Importance of Leash Training

Leash training is an essential aspect of owning a dog. It ensures our furry friends’ safety and allows us to maintain control and manage their behavior effectively. Leash training lays the foundation for other types of training and helps create a strong bond between us and our dogs.

In this article, we will explore the benefits of leash training, everyday issues that may arise during the process, and how to choose the right leash and collar for our canine companions.

The Benefits of Leash Training

Leash training offers numerous benefits for both dogs and their owners. One of the primary advantages is ensuring the safety of our dogs while out on walks or in public spaces. Keeping our dogs on a leash can prevent them from darting into traffic, chasing after other animals, or getting lost.

Leash training also helps establish boundaries and teaches dogs to stay close to us, which can be particularly useful in busy and crowded areas.

Moreover, leash training allows us to control our dogs’ behavior. It helps prevent them from jumping on people, pulling excessively, or exhibiting aggressive behavior toward other dogs or pedestrians. We can enjoy our walks without stress or concern by teaching our dogs proper leash manners.

Furthermore, leash training is a crucial component of socialization. It allows our dogs to interact with the world around them while simultaneously teaching them appropriate behavior. Through positive experiences and exposure to different situations, dogs become well-adjusted and confident in various environments.

Common Issues with Leash Training

While leash training is essential, it can face its fair share of challenges. One common issue is excessive pulling. Our dogs may tug and lunge on the leash, making walks unpleasant and challenging to manage. This behavior can be both frustrating and physically straining for us as owners.

Another common issue is leash reactivity or aggression towards other dogs or people. Some dogs exhibit protective or fearful behavior when on a leash, which can lead to lunging, barking, or growling. These behaviors can make walking our dogs a stressful experience and may even put others at risk.

Lastly, some dogs may struggle with leash training due to distractions or fear. They may become fixated on the environment, such as squirrels, cars, or other animals, making it challenging to redirect their attention and focus on us.

Choosing the Right Leash and Collar

Selecting our dogs’ right leash and collar is crucial for practical leash training. Various options are available, each catering to different training needs and preferences.

When choosing a leash, we have several options, including standard leashes, retractable leashes, and long lines. Standard leashes are typically made of nylon or leather and come in various lengths. They offer sufficient control and are suitable for most situations. Retractable leashes provide more freedom for dogs to explore but should be used cautiously, as they can pose safety hazards if not properly managed. Long lines are ideal for training, allowing our dogs more movement space while maintaining control.

In terms of collars, traditional flat collars are commonly used for dogs. However, harnesses may be better if our dogs tend to pull or exhibit leash reactivity. Harnesses distribute the pulling force across the dog’s chest and back, reducing strain on the neck and potentially preventing injuries.

Understanding the Different Types of Dog Harnesses

Dog harnesses come in various styles, each serving specific purposes. Understanding the different types can help us choose the most appropriate harness for our dogs’ needs and improve our leash training experience.

Front-Clip Harnesses

Front-clip harnesses have a ring on the front of the chest, allowing us to attach the leash. When our dogs pull, the harness redirects their forward momentum, causing them to face us instead. This mechanism discourages pulling and helps us regain control more easily. Front-clip harnesses are particularly useful for dogs prone to pulling or exhibiting leash-reactive behavior.

Back-Clip Harnesses

Back-clip harnesses have a ring on the back, near the dog’s shoulder blades, where we can attach the leash. This type of harness is more suitable for dogs with established leash manners and minimal pulling tendencies. While back-clip harnesses may not directly address pulling issues, they still provide control and distribute the pulling force more evenly.

No-Pull Harnesses

No-pull harnesses are designed explicitly to deter pulling behavior. They often have additional features, such as front and back clips or attachments on the sides, which allow us to control our dogs from multiple angles. No-pull harnesses usually have straps that tighten when dogs pull, creating a sensation that discourages pulling. These harnesses benefit dogs who require extra help in breaking the habit of pulling.

Safety Considerations

When choosing a dog harness, we must prioritize safety. The harness should fit properly, allowing our dogs to move comfortably without causing chafing or restricted movement. We must measure our dogs’ chest circumference and adjust the harness accordingly. Additionally, the material should be sturdy and durable, able to withstand our dogs’ strength and any potential pulling or tugging. Regular harness inspections for wear and tear are essential to ensure it remains in good condition.

Comparing Dog Harnesses and Collars

While collars have long been the go-to choice for controlling dogs, harnesses have gained popularity due to their numerous advantages. Let’s explore the alternatives and understand why harnesses may be a better option for leash training.

Traditional Collars and Their Effects on Pulling

Traditional collars include a strap around the neck, with a buckle or clip for attachment. While collars can be effective for dogs with good leash manners, they can exacerbate pulling issues in dogs prone to pulling or exhibiting leash reactivity. The pressure exerted on the neck when a dog pulls on a collar can cause discomfort, pain, and potential injury. Moreover, collars may not distribute the pulling force as effectively as harnesses, leading to an increased risk of neck and trachea injuries.

Harnesses as an Alternative to Collars

Harnesses are an alternative to collars, offering a safer and more comfortable option for leash training. By distributing the pulling force across the dog’s body, harnesses reduce the strain on the neck and minimize the risk of injuries. They provide greater control over the dog’s movements and allow more effective redirection and correction. Harnesses also help prevent choking or gagging associated with collar usage, particularly in dogs prone to pulling or exerting significant force on the leash.

The Effectiveness of Different Types of Harnesses

The effectiveness of harnesses in leash training depends on several factors, including the type of harness, the individual dog, and the training approach. Front-clip harnesses are generally considered more effective for addressing pulling issues, as they redirect the dog’s forward momentum, encouraging them to face us instead. Back-clip and no-pull harnesses can also be effective, depending on the dog’s behavior and training needs.

It is worth noting that some dogs may require a combination of training techniques, such as positive reinforcement and redirection, in conjunction with a harness. Each dog is unique, and it may take some trial and error to determine which harness and training approach best suits their needs.

Do Dog Harnesses Encourage Pulling?

Whether dog harnesses encourage pulling has been debated among dog owners and trainers. To understand this issue better, let’s explore the theory, studies, and factors influencing pulling behavior.

The Theory Behind Harnesses and Pulling

Some believe using a harness may inadvertently reinforce pulling behavior in dogs. This theory posits that the sensation of pressure against the harness, particularly with back-clip harnesses, can be a form of positive reinforcement for pulling. According to this line of thinking, dogs may associate pulling with the sensation of forward movement and continue to pull to maintain that momentum.

Studies on Dog Harnesses and Pulling Behavior

Studies on dog harnesses and pulling behavior have yielded varied results, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions. Some studies have suggested that harnesses do not significantly impact removing behavior and are neither more nor less likely to encourage pulling than collars. However, other studies have shown that certain types of harnesses, such as front-clip harnesses, can effectively reduce pulling tendencies.

While some dogs may exhibit initial resistance or confusion when introduced to a harness, proper training and reinforcement can help mitigate any potential adverse effects. Combining harness usage with positive reinforcement techniques is essential to teach our dogs proper leash manners and discourage pulling behaviors.

Factors That Influence Pulling Behavior

Several factors can influence dog-pulling behavior, regardless of the equipment used. These factors include the dog’s temperament, prior training experiences, breed tendencies, and level of distractions in the environment. It is crucial to address these factors holistically when attempting to reduce pulling behavior.

Consistent training, positive reinforcement, and gradual exposure to distracting environments can all contribute to improving leash behavior.

Setting realistic expectations and understanding that the journey to leash manners may take time and patience is essential. Seeking the guidance of a professional dog trainer or behaviorist can be beneficial, especially if pulling issues persist despite our best efforts.

Do Dogs Pull More With A Harness?

How to Properly Leash Train Your Dog with a Harness

Leash training with a harness requires patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement. These steps can help our dogs develop good leash manners and enjoy stress-free walks.

Positive Reinforcement and Reward-Based Training

Positive reinforcement is at the core of practical leash training. It involves rewarding our dogs for desired behaviors, such as walking calmly by our side, looking at us for guidance, or maintaining loose leash tension. Rewards can include treats, praise, playtime, or anything else that motivates our dogs. By associating positive experiences with desired behaviors, we can encourage our dogs to repeat these behaviors in the future.

Steps for Leash Training with a Harness

  1. Introduce the harness gradually: Allow our dogs to get comfortable with the harness by associating it with positive experiences. Gradually increase the time our dogs wear the harness, starting with short periods and gradually extending the duration over several days.
  2. Make the harness a positive experience: Use treats and praise to create positive associations with the harness. Reward our dogs when they show interest in or approach the harness willingly. This helps them view the harness as something enjoyable rather than a restraint.
  3. Practice wearing the harness indoors: Once our dogs are comfortable wearing the harness, attach the leash and practice walking indoors. Encourage them to walk by our side using positive reinforcement techniques.
  4. Gradually transition to outdoor walks: Start with quiet areas and progress to more distracting environments. Use positive reinforcement to reward our dogs for walking calmly by our side, maintaining loose leash tension, or following basic cues. Remember to be patient and gradually increase the difficulty level as our dogs become more comfortable and proficient.

Dealing with Pulling Issues

If our dogs exhibit pulling behavior, addressing it consistently and patiently is crucial. Avoid pulling back forcefully on the leash, which may exacerbate the problem. Instead, use redirection techniques, such as changing direction or stopping when pulling occurs.

Reward our dogs when they return to our site or maintain loose leash tension. Consistency and positive reinforcement will help our dogs understand that walking calmly by our side is rewarding and enjoyable.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Using a Dog Harness

While harnesses can be valuable tools for leash training, avoiding common mistakes that may hinder our dogs’ progress and potentially lead to discomfort or injuries is essential.

Using the Wrong Size or Fit

Using a too-tight or loose harness can cause discomfort and restrict our dogs’ movement. It is crucial to accurately measure our dogs’ chest circumference and choose a harness size that fits snugly but allows them to move comfortably. Regularly reassess the fit of the harness, as dogs may gain or lose weight over time.

Improper Adjustment of the Harness

Adjusting the harness incorrectly can lead to discomfort and ineffective control. Ensure the straps are securely fastened but not too tight, allowing proper movement.

The leash attachment should be centered on the dog’s chest for front-clip harnesses and positioned near the shoulder blades for back-clip harnesses. Make necessary adjustments and regularly monitor the fit to avoid slipping or chafing.

Inadequate Training and Reinforcement

Simply using a harness does not guarantee perfect leash manners. Adequate training and reinforcement are essential to teach our dogs how to walk calmly on a leash.

Consistency, positive reinforcement, and patience are key. Regular training sessions and reinforcement of desired behaviors will help our dogs develop good leash manners.

Do Dogs Pull More With A Harness?

Training Tools and Techniques to Reduce Pulling

In addition to using a harness, several training tools and techniques can be employed to reduce further pulling behavior and improve leash manners.

Using a Front-Clip Harness for Training

Front-clip harnesses help train dogs to walk politely on a leash. When our dogs pull, the harness redirects their forward momentum, making it easier to regain control. With positive reinforcement techniques, front-clip harnesses can discourage pulling and encourage desirable leash behavior.

Implementing Loose Leash Walking Techniques

Loose leash walking techniques focus on teaching our dogs to walk calmly without tension on the leash.

One effective technique is to stop and stand still whenever our dogs pull, waiting for them to return to our side before resuming the walk. This teaches our dogs that pulling does not lead to forward progress while walking calmly by our side is rewarded with continued movement.

Scent-Based Training to Distract from Pulling

Scent-based training can help distract our dogs from distractions and reduce pulling tendencies.

Using scent-marked objects or treats strategically placed along the walk, we can encourage our dogs to focus on the trail rather than pulling or fixating on external stimuli. Scent-based training engages our dogs’ instincts and provides mental stimulation during walks, making them more enjoyable and immersive experiences.

The Role of Breed and Size in Pulling Behavior

Breed and size can influence pulling behavior in dogs. While every dog is an individual, certain breed tendencies and characteristics may predispose them to pulling more or less than others.

Working and Sporting Breeds

Working and sporting breeds, such as Huskies, Retrievers, and Pointers, are bred for tasks that require pulling or stamina. These breeds may have a stronger inclination to pull and may benefit from more specialized training techniques tailored to their instincts and tendencies. However, with proper training, all dogs can learn good leash manners, regardless of breed or background.

Small Breed Dogs

Although smaller dogs may not have the same physical strength as larger breeds, they can still exhibit pulling behaviors. Small breed dogs often display high energy levels and enthusiasm, which can lead to pulling on the leash.

Harnesses are particularly suitable for smaller dogs, providing better control and reducing strain on their delicate necks.

Understanding Individual Differences

While breed tendencies can provide some insight into pulling behavior, it is crucial to remember that every dog is an individual.

Some dogs may naturally be inclined to pull, while others may be more responsive to leash training from the start. Understanding and accommodating our dogs’ differences can help us tailor our training approaches and techniques to their needs.

Do Dogs Pull More With A Harness?

When to Seek Professional Help for Pulling Issues

Professional help may be necessary to address persistent pulling issues or more concerning behaviors in certain instances. Consulting with a certified dog trainer or behaviorist can provide valuable insights, guidance, and support in overcoming challenging leash behaviors.

Persistent Pulling Despite Training

If our dogs continue to exhibit significant pulling behaviors despite consistent training efforts, it may be wise to seek professional help. A certified dog trainer or behaviorist can assess the situation, identify underlying causes, and provide specialized training techniques tailored to our dogs’ needs.

Aggressive or Reactive Pulling Behaviors

If our dogs display aggressive or reactive pulling behaviors, such as lunging, growling, or barking, it is essential to seek help from a professional. These behaviors can pose risks to our dogs and others, and addressing them requires professional guidance and expertise.

Consulting with a Certified Dog Trainer or Behaviorist

Certified dog trainers and behaviorists have the knowledge and experience to address complex leash behaviors and underlying issues.

They can provide tailored training plans, behavior modification techniques, and guidance on managing and preventing future incidents. Seeking professional help can improve our dogs’ leash manners and overall behavior.


Leash training is a fundamental aspect of owning a dog and is crucial in ensuring their safety, allowing for effective control, and fostering positive interactions with the environment.

Choosing the right leash and collar, understanding the different types of dog harnesses, and implementing positive reinforcement techniques are all essential steps in achieving successful leash training.

While pulling issues can arise, we can help our dogs develop good leash manners and enjoy stress-free walks with patience, consistency, and the proper tools and techniques.

Remember, each dog is unique, so individualize the training approach based on their needs, and don’t hesitate to seek professional help if necessary. Happy leash training!

Do Dogs Pull More With A Harness?

Previous articleHow Long Should A Dog Leash Be?
Next articleIs There A Humane Bark Collar?
Brian Moore
I'm Brian Moore, a veterinarian with over 10 years of experience. I graduated from the University of California, Davis School of Veterinary Medicine in 2012. After graduation, I worked as a general practitioner in a small animal clinic for several years. In 2017, I opened my own veterinary practice, Moore Animal Hospital. I'm passionate about providing compassionate and high-quality care to all animals. I'm skilled in a wide range of veterinary procedures, including surgery, dentistry, and internal medicine. I'm also a certified animal behaviorist, and I take a special interest in helping animals with behavioral problems. In addition to my clinical work, I'm also active in the veterinary community. I'm a member of the American Veterinary Medical Association and the California Veterinary Medical Association. I'm also a frequent speaker at veterinary conferences. I'm dedicated to providing the best possible care for my patients and their families. I'm a compassionate and knowledgeable veterinarian who is always willing to go the extra mile. I'm originally from San Francisco, California. I'm married and have two children. I enjoy hiking, camping, and spending time with my family. I'm also a member of the local animal shelter and volunteer my time to help care for homeless animals. I'm excited to continue my career as a veterinarian and help even more animals in need.